The Decisions – 11/12

 

Below is a list of every decision we have made, separated into teams, for and against. Perfect for those of you who don’t fancy reading each individual blog, which is where you will find in depth explanations for our decisions. Enjoy.

Arsenal

For
Song stamp against Newcastle.
Arshavin avoiding second yellow against Man Utd.
Thomas penalty shout against West Brom.
Song not shown red card against Wolves.
Milijas red card against Wolves.
Drenthe disallowed goal against Everton.

Against
Gervinho penalty shout against Newcastle.
First goal for Liverpool offside.
Evra penalty against Man Utd.
Robinson tackle on Walcott no pen in Blackburn game.
Robinson tackle on Walcott no red card in Blackburn game.
Van Der Vaart handball against Spurs.
Chamakh penalty shout against Stoke.
Santos fouled in build up to Mata goal against Chelsea.
Young handball in area against QPR.
Gervinho penalty shout against Fulham.
Djourou second yellow against Fulham.
Nathan Dyer penalty against Swansea.
Bale penalty against Spurs.
Suarez penalty against Liverpool.
Gardner no red against Aston Villa.
Van Persie penalty shout against Man City.
Balotelli no red for tackle on Song against Man City.

Aston Villa

For
Alan Hutton tackle on Long no red card shown against West Brom.
Odemwingie goal disallowed for offside against West Brom.
Free kick in build up to goal against Sunderland.
Warnock hand ball in build up to goal against Norwich.
Saha penalty shout agaisnt Everton.
Gardner no red against Arsenal.
Baker handball in area not given against Man Utd.
Suarez penalty shout against Liverpool.
Kuyt penalty shout against Liverpool.
Ball over line, but not given against Liverpool.
Bendtner goal ruled out for offside against Sunderland.
Hutton handball not given and no red shown against West Brom.

Against
Herd red card against West Brom
Penalty awarded against West Brom.
Agger handball penalty shout against Liverpool.
Young penalty against Man Utd.
Collins penalty shout against Stoke.
Free which led to goal for Stoke.
Penalty shout turned down for Brunt handball against West Brom.
Penalty shout turned down for Olsson handball against West brom.

Blackburn

For
Formica second penalty against Everton.
Robinson tackle on Walcott no pen in Arsenal game.
Moses penalty shout against Wigan.
Hoilett goal against Wigan.
N’Zonzi elbows no red cards x2 against Stoke.
Dann goal given despite being offside against West Brom.
Sigurdsson penalty shout against Swansea.

Against
Fellaini penalty against Everton.
Penalty awarded to Norwich.
Disallowed goal against Sunderland.
Paul Robsinson penalty foul against Bolton.
Samba goal disallowed against Stoke.
Fellaini handball in build up to Everton goal.
Hoillett penalty shout against Bolton.
Flanagan no second yellow against Liverpool.
Martin handball penalty shout against Norwich.

Bolton

For
Richards’ goal disallowed against Man City.
Paul Robinson back pass against Liverpool.
Suarez penalty shout against Liverpool.
Goal scored offside against Chelsea.
Penalty awarded against Wigan.
Goal as result of pass back against Stoke.
Long penalty shout against West Brom.
Davies hand ball in area against Everton.
Paul Robinson penalty foul against Blackburn.
Knight no red for penalty against Man Utd.
Knight handball in Liverpool game.
Balotelli penalty shouts against Man City x2.
Hill goal disallowed against QPR.
Hoillett penalty shout against Blackburn.
Davies penalty awarded against Wolves.

Against
Davies goal ruled out for offside against Chelsea.
Cahill red card against Spurs.
FK that led to goal incorrectly given against Wolves.
Cisse goal given, but offside against QPR.
Cisse goal given, but offside against Newcastle.
Goal ruled out for Mark Davies offside against Sunderland.

Chelsea

For
Cole tackle on Hernandez no red card against Man Utd.
Davies goal disallowed for offside against Chelsea.
Santos fouled in build up to Mata goal against Chelsea.
Luiz foul on Ba no red shown against Newcastle.
David Silva penalty shout against Man City.
Bendtner penalty shout against Sunderland.
Malouda stamp no red at Swansea.
Ivanovic goal given, but offside against Wigan.
Mata goal given, but offside against Wigan.

Against
Torres penalty shout against Stoke.
Lampard penalty shout against Stoke.
Smalling goal offside against Man Utd.
Goal scored offside against Chelsea.
Helguson penalty against QPR.
Luiz penalty shout against Chelsea.
Toure kick and slap on Mata against Man City.
Kompany second yellow offence against Man City.
Torres penalty shout against Sunderland x2.
Welbeck penalty against Man Utd.
Ramires penalty shout against Spurs.
Kelly handball in area not given against Fulham.
Lampard penalty shout for Hangeland foul against Fulham.

Everton

For
Fellaini penalty against Blackburn.
Osman penalty against Sunderland.
Modric penalty shout against Spurs.
Fellaini handball in build up to goal against Blackburn.
Pienaar lying on ball in build up to goal against Norwich.

Against
Formica second penalty against Blackburn.
Rodwell red against Liverpool.
Gosling handball in area against Everton.
Cahill penalty shout against Wolves.
Davies handball in area against Bolton.
Fellaini penalty shout against Stoke.
Holt elbow on Fellaini against Norwich.
Drenthe penalty shout against Spurs.
Saha penalty shout against Villa.
Drenthe disallowed goal against Arsenal.

Fulham

For
Suarez goal ruled out for offside against Liverpool.
Welbeck penalty shout against Man Utd.
Djourou second yellow against Arsenal.
Gervinho penalty shout against Arsenal.
Duff penalty against Newcastle.
Silva penalty shout against Man City.
Kelly handball in area not given against Chelsea.
Lampard penalty shout for Hangeland foul against Chelsea.

Against
Walker hand ball in area against Spurs.
Johnson penalty against Man City.
Murphy penalty shout against Man Utd.

Liverpool

For
First goal against Arsenal offside.
Carroll push on Johnson in build up to goal against Wolves.
Rodwell red against Everton.
Adam dive for fk that led to goal against Man Utd.
Balotelli second yellow against Man City.
Agger handball penalty shout against Aston Villa.
Skrtel no red against Spurs.
Suarez penalty against Arsenal.
Flanagan no second yellow against Blackburn.

Against
Andy Carroll disallowed goal against Sunderland.
Paul Robinson back pass against Bolton.
Suarez penalty shout against Bolton.
Delap handball in area against Stoke.
Reid handball in area against West Brom.
Suarez goal ruled out for offside against Fulham.
Cabaye tackle worthy of red against Newcastle.
Carrol penalty shout against Stoke x2.
Knight handball against Bolton.
Adam penalty shout against Wolves.
Carroll penalty shout against Spurs.
Carroll penalty shout against Newcastle.
Simpson handball in area and no red card shown against Newcastle.
Cisse goal offside against Newcastle.
Suarez penalty shout against Aston Villa.
Kuyt penalty shout against Aston Villa.
Ball over line, but not given against Aston Villa.
Maxi penalty shout against West Brom.

Man City

For
Toure kick and slap on Mata against Chelsea.
Kompany second yellow offence on Mata against Chelsea.
Lescott elbow on Kaboul against Spurs.
Balotelli stamp on Parker against Spurs.
Johnson penalty against Fulham.
Whelan penalty shout against Stoke.
Van Persie penalty shout against Arsenal.
Balotelli no red for tackle on Song against Arsenal.

Against
Richards’ goal disallowed against Bolton.
Richards penalty shout against Man Utd.
Free kick in build up to opening goal against QPR.
Balotelli second yellow against Liverpool.
David Silva penalty shout against Chelsea.
Ji goal should have been called offside against Sunderland.
Silva penalty shout against Fulham.
Balotelli penalty shouts against Bolton x2.
Swansea penalty.
Tevez penalty shout against Norwich.

Man Utd

For
Evra penalty against Arsenal.
Smalling goal offside against Chelsea.
Richards penalty shout against Man Utd.
Sammon red card against Wigan.
Welbeck penalty against Chelsea.
Young penalty against West Brom.
Murphy penalty shout against Fulham.
Young penalty against Aston Villa.
Derry red card and Young penalty against QPR.
Moses goal disallowed against Wigan.
Evans second yellow foul not given against Wigan.

Against
Arshavin avoiding a second yellow against Arsenal.
Cole tackle on Hernandez no red card against Chelsea.
Hernandez penalty shout against Stoke.
Adam dive for FK which led to goal against Liverpool.
Penalty conceded against Newcastle.
Welbeck goal ruled out for offside against QPR.
Welbeck penalty shout against Fulham.
Hernandez penalty shout against Wigan.
Knight no red for penalty against Bolton.
Evra penalty shout against Stoke.
Baker handball in area not given against Aston Villa.
Corner which led to goal against Wigan.
Welbeck penalty shout against Wigan.
Figueroa handball in area not given against Wigan.

Newcastle

For
Gerivnho penalty shout against Arsenal.
Cabeye tackle that earned yellow instead of red against Sunderland.
O’Hara penalty shout against Wolves.
Doyle disallowed goal against Wolves.
Gosling hand ball in area against Everton.
Penalty awarded against Man Utd.
Santon handball in area against Norwich.
Cabaye tackle worthy of red against Liverpool.
Defoe penalty shout against Spurs.
Carroll penalty shout against Liverpool.
Simpson handball in area not given and no red card shown against Liverpool.
Cisse goal given, but offside against Liverpool.
Cisse goal given, but offside against Bolton.

Against
Song stamp against Arsenal.
Larsson handball on line against Sunderland.
Luiz foul on Ba no red shown against Chelsea.
Gosling red card against Norwich.
Krul corner not over line against Norwich.
Derry no red for Cabaye tackle against QPR.
Duff penalty against Fulham.
Adebayor handball in area against Spurs.
Cattermole no red card against Sunderland.
Cisse goal ruled out for offside against Stoke.
Alcaraz handball, no second yellow against Wigan.

Norwich

For
Di Santo penalty shout against Wigan.
Barnett foul on Klasnic no red shown against Bolton.
Lita penalty shout against Swansea.
Penalty awarded against Blackburn.
Gosling red card against Newcastle.
Krul corner not over line against Newcastle.
Holt elbow on Fellaini against Everton.
Gallas penalty shout against Spurs.
Ayala no red for tackle against West Brom.
FK that led to goal against Swansea.
Tevez penalty shout against Man City.
Martin handball penalty shout against Blackburn.

Against
Di Santo penalty given against Wigan.
Leon Barnett penalty decisions against Stoke.
Leon Barnett red card against Stoke.
Reid penalty against West Brom.
Tamas elbow and penalty not given against West Brom.
Warnock handball in build up to Aston Villa goal.
Santon hanball in area against Newcastle.
Throw in that led to goal for Stoke.
Whitbread penalty shout against Wolves.
Pienaar lying on ball in build up to goal against Everton.
Holt penalty shout and subsequent Spurs goal scored.
Kaboul kick on Holt no red shown against Spurs.
Wilbraham penalty shout against Spurs.

QPR

For
Stearman penalty shout against Wolves.
Helguson penalty against Chelsea.
Luiz penalty shout against Chelsea.
Free kick in build up to opening goal against Man City.
Pennant penalty shout against Stoke.
Welbeck goal ruled out for offside against Man Utd.
Young handball in area against Arsenal.
Graham penalty shout against Swansea.
Derry tackle no red against Newcastle.
Cisse goal given, but offside against Bolton.
Free kick that led to goal against Spurs.

Against
Henry tackle on Barton no red against Wolves.
Wright-Phillips goal ruled out for offside against West Brom.
FK that led to goal against Wigan.
Hill goal disallowed against Bolton.
Derry red card and Young penalty against Man Utd.

Spurs

For
Van Der Vaart handball against Arsenal.
Walker hand ball in area against Fulham.
Lennon penalty against West Brom.
Cahill red card against Bolton.
Modric penalty against Stoke.
Drenthe penalty shout against Everton.
Assou-Ekotto stamp against Wigan.
Carroll penalty shout against Liverpool.
Adebayor handball in area against Newcastle.
Bale penalty against Arsenal.
Ramires penalty shout against Chelsea.
Holt penalty shout and subsequent goal scored against Norwich.
Kaboul kick on Holt no red shown against Norwich.
Wilbraham penalty shout against Norwich.

Against
Crouch handball against Stoke.
Kaboul penalty shout against Stoke.
Adebayor offside goal against Stoke.
Shawcross handball in area against Stoke.
Kaboul second yellow against Stoke.
Gallas penalty shout against Norwich.
Modric penalty shout against Everton.
Adebayor disallowed goal against Wolves.
Wolves goal should have been a goal kick.
Lescott elbow on Kaboul against Man City.
Balotelli stamp on Parker against Man City.
Skrtel no red against Liverpool.
Defoe penalty shout against Newcastle.
Bardsley handball in area not given against Sunderland.
Free kick that led to goal against QPR.

Stoke

For
Torres penalty shout against Chelsea.
Lampard penalty shout against Chelsea.
Leon Barnett penalty decisions against Norwich.
Leon Barnett red card against Norwich.
Shotton goal taking ball from Foster’s hands against West Brom.
Delap handball in area against Liverpool.
Hernandez penalty shout against Man Utd.
Wilkinson tackle worthy of red card against Swansea.
Chamakh penalty shout against Arsenal.
Fellaini penalty shout against Everton.
Crouch handball against Spurs.
Kaboul penalty shout against Spurs.
Adebayor offside goal against Spurs.
Shawcross handball in area against Spurs.
Kaboul second yellow against Spurs.
Samba goal disallowed against Blackburn.
Carrol penalty shout against Liverpool x2.
Walters penalty against West Brom.
Evra penalty shout against Man Utd.
Throw in that led to goal against Norwich.
Whitehead handball in area not given against Wigan.
Collins penalty shout against Aston Villa.
Free kick which led to goal against Aston Villa.

Against
Walters penalty shout against Swansea.
Bolton goal as result of pass back.
Pennant penalty shout against QPR.
N’Zonzi elbows no red cards x2 against Blackburn.
Modric penalty against Spurs.
Huth red card against Sunderland.
Whelan pealty shout against Man City.
Crouch penalty shout against Wolves.

Sunderland

For
Andy Carroll disallowed goal against Liverpool.
Larsson handball on line against Newcastle.
Cattermole tackle should have earned second yellow against West Brom.
Larsson penalty against Wolves.
Diasllowed goal against Blackburn.
Ji goal should have been disallowed against Man City.
Torres penalty shout against Chelsea x2.
Huth red card against Stoke.
Cattermole no red card against Newcastle.
Bardsley handball in area not given against Spurs.
Goal ruled out for Mark Davies offside against Bolton.

Against
Cabeye tackle that earned yellow instead of red against Newcastle.
Free kick in build up to Aston Villa goal.
Moses penalty against Wigan.
O’Shea penalty shout against Wolves.
O’Hara handball in area against Wolves.
Osman penalty against Everton.
Bendtner penalty shout against Sunderland.
Campbell goal ruled out for offside against West Brom.
Bendtner goal ruled out for offside against Aston Villa.

Swansea

For
Brunt disallowed goal against West Brom.
Walters penalty shout against Stoke.
Dyer penalty against Arsenal.
Williams handball in area against West Brom.
Penalty against Man City.

Against
Wilkinson tackle worthy of red card against Stoke.
Lita penalty shout against Norwich.
Graham penalty shout against QPR.
Morrisson no red against West Brom.
FK that led to goal against Norwich.
Dyer red card against Wigan.
Sigurdsson penalty shout against Blackburn.

West Brom

For
Reid penalty against Newcastle.
Tamas elbow and penalty not given against Norwich.
Chris Herd red card against Aston Villa.
Penalty awarded against Aston Villa.
Reid handball in area against Liverpool.
Wright Philips goal ruled out against QPR.
Morrisson no red against Swansea.
Campbell goal ruled out for offside against Sunderland.
Mulumbu no red against Wigan.
Maxi penalty shout against Liverpool.
Penalty shout turned down for Brunt handball against Aston Villa.
Penalty shout turned down for Olsson handball against West Brom.

Against
Shotton goal taking ball from Foster’s hands against Stoke.
Brunt disallowed goal against Swansea.
Cattermole tackle should have earned second yellow against Sunderland.
Johnson last man tackle on Long against Wolves.
Olsson penalty shout against Wolves.
Hutton tackle on Long no red card against Aston Villa.
Odemwingie goal disallowed for offside against Aston Villa.
Thomas penalty shout against Arsenal.
Long penalty shout against Bolton.
Lennon penalty against Spurs.
Dann goal given despite being offside against Blackburn.
Ayala no red for penalty tackle against Norwich.
Walters penalty against Stoke.
Williams handball in area against Swansea.
Young penalty against Man Utd.
No penalty or red card for Hutton handball against Aston Villa.

Wigan

For
Di Santo penalty given against Norwich.
Alcaraz spit against Wolves.
Moses penalty against Sunderland.
FK that led to goal against QPR.
Dyer red card against Swansea.
Corner which led to goal against Man Utd.
Welbeck penalty shout against Man Utd.
Figueroa handball in area not given against Man Utd.
No second yellow for Alcaraz handball against Newcastle.

Against
Di Santo penalty shout against Norwich.
Penalty awarded to Bolton.
Moses penalty shout against Blackburn.
Hoilett goal against Blackburn.
Assou-Ekotto no red against Spurs.
Sammon red card against Man Utd.
Mulumbu no red against West Brom.
Whitehead handball in area not given against Stoke.
Ivanovic goal offside not given against Chelsea.
Mata goal offside not given against Chelsea.
Moses goal disallowed against Man Utd.
Evans second yellow not given against Man Utd.

Wolves

For
Henry tackle on Barton no red against QPR.
Olsson penalty shout against West Brom.
Cahill penalty shout against Everton.
O’Shea penalty shout against Sunderland.
O’Hara hand ball against Sunderland.
Johnson last man tackle on Long against West Brom.
FK that led to goal incorrectly given against Bolton.
Goal against Spurs should have been a goal kick.
Adebayor disallowed goal against Spurs.
Adam penalty shout against Liveprool.
Whitbread penalty shout against Norwich.
Crouch penalty shout against Stoke.

Against
Stearman penalty shout against QPR.
Carroll push on Johnson in build up to goal against Liverpool.
O’Hara penalty shout against Newcastle.
Doyle disallowed goal against Newcastle.
Alcaraz spit against Wigan.
Larsson penalty against Sunderland.
Song not given red card against Arsenal.
Milijas red card against Arsenal.
Davies penalty awarded against Bolton.

Tags: , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , ,

22 Responses to “The Decisions – 11/12”

  1. Matthew Williamson says:

    What about Yakubu offside goal v Arsenal?

  2. William Thomas says:

    On the Wolves list you seem to be missing a few

    v Stoke – failure to send off Woodgate
    v Stoke – incorrect free kick from which Stoke scored
    v Chelsea – winner scored by Lampard who should have been sent off, from a cross by Cole who should have been sent off

  3. Xobbo says:

    @William Thomas

    They were CORRECT decisions, this is only a list of incorrect ones.

  4. Mike says:

    @Matthew Williamson -

    This is a list of incorrect decisions only. I looked back at the Blackburn-Arsenal game and we gave the Yakubu one as a correct decision. It does appear he was level, although you’re welcome to disagree with that, as it was very marginal. We reached our decisions by taking a majority verdict from the decisions given by five judges. Our majority verdict was that Yakubu’s goal was right to stand.

  5. xnnx says:

    what Carroll penalty shout against Liverpool. ?

  6. Simon says:

    The one where the ball was chipped towards Carroll just inside the area from deep, Dawson pushes him forwar din order to get to the ball first.

  7. Keir says:

    You see, we’d be above the filthy mags and into europe if the stupid refs didnt muck up.

  8. Paul K says:

    The real table is incorrect. Sunderland are actually on 43 pts not 49 pts. I haven’t checked the other teams though.

  9. hasan says:

    you forgot suarez penalty shout against aston villa

  10. hasan says:

    and victor moses dissalowed goal against manu from the corner

  11. Simon says:

    I do not see any mention of the the 88th minute obvious penalty on Danny Murphy in Man U- Fulham match. Also the two dives of Ashley Young against QPR and Aston Villa are not listed. The list is not complete.

  12. Simon says:

    This list hasn’t been updated in a few weeks, the incidents mentioned have been included in the tables though. I’ll try to get this up to date asap.

  13. JuanMata says:

    Nani’s goal against Chelsea at Old Trafford was also offside!
    u clearly havent taken all decisions into account!!

  14. Simon says:

    We have, it was considered in the original blog about that weekend’s round of games.

  15. Nick says:

    What about United getting the non-call on the penalty shout Fulham had at the end of that game, Ashley Young’s offside penalty against QPR, Ashley Young diving to get Derry sent off against QPR, Ashley Young diving to get the penalty against Aston Villa?

  16. Simon says:

    Again, as I said only a few comments ago, this has not been updated in a while. We’ll try and get it up to date asap.

    Edit – It has been updated now.

  17. Nick says:

    I was just confused because the league table was nearly up to date

  18. Dean says:

    Can’t say I agree about the Spurs/Arsenal decisions.

    Clearly hit VDV’shoulder/chest and as for the Bale penalty, replays showed Clichy bringing him down — if anything, Arsenal got the incorrect decision by not having Clichy sent off.

  19. hasan says:

    flanagans 2nd yellow doenst matter because he got doni sent off if he never did the back pass

  20. John says:

    What about Stephen Kellys (Fulham) handball in the box against Manchester United in the first half?? Game was played on OT.

  21. has says:

    arsenal where only cheated 3 points and liverpool where cheated by 11 points and at the other end of the spectrum stoke cheated 15 points off teams

Leave a Reply