We’re back! It’s been a hell of a wait for us to catch up with the weeks we missed, but we’re finally getting there. Unfortunately work commitments and holidays meant that I didn’t have the capacity to keep our judges up to date on the decision on a weekly basis, but as promised we continue [...]
A quiet week in Debatable Decisions towers as we looked at Week 22 of the Premier League season and had just a handful of decisions to cover, however, at least one of those decisions provided one of the most heated discussions amongst all football fans this season. Good old Vincent Kompany and the FA. Enjoy! [...]
Round 20 and 21 of the Premier League season, we’ve back on schedule after the FA Cup games and the referees of the Premier League were kind enough to provide us with a whole host of decisions to consider, a decent number of which they got wrong. Well done them. Enjoy! Arsenal – Newcastle Free [...]
Two game days in one and finally up to date. Well played to our judges for having the stamina to sift through 31 big debatable decisions. A happy New Year to all of them and all of you too. Enjoy! Man City – Reading Tabb Penalty Shout (Not Given) Simon M – I think there [...]
The holiday season was a complete washout in Debatable Decisions towers, with DD overlord Simon McPolin laid low with the Norovirus bug that gave Brendan Rodgers gonorrhoea…..according the official Liverpool Twitter account. Anyway, time to play catch up. Enjoy! Liverpool – Aston Villa Agger Penalty Shout (Not Given) Simon M – I think there’s enough [...]
Week 16 of the Premier League season and the judges were working overtime to cope with the amount of big debatable referee decisions that took place last weekend, of which an incredible 16 were incorrect. Wowzers. For future reference, there are a few decisions included this week that weren’t include din the Match of the [...]
As we did last season, this is a list of all the big incorrect refereeing decisions we have judged this season broken down into teams, for and against. We have covered every single Premier League game so far, and we’re the only site available that offers such a comprehensive service, so if you think we’ve [...]
Offside calls and free kicks that led to goals were the order of the week for round thirteen of the Premier League and, for the most part, they were all pretty clear cut and easily judged. There’s always space for a really dodgy penalty, though and Liam Ridgewell did his best to remind us that [...]
Week 10 of the Premier League season sees the return of Debatable Decisions overlord Simon McPolin, me. Many thanks to Simon Furnivall for stepping in whilst I took a rest from casting a condescending eye over referees. In that time we’ve lost two judges, Mike and Ant deciding that it was one handball decision too [...]
It’s Week 5 of the Premier League season and all of a sudden referees and teams have decided to go buck mad, with over 20 big debatable decisions for the team to discuss this week. Going through these was tough going and probably tired our judges out, which is why we failed to get a [...]
